The Writers Of Predator Had Incredible Plans For A Sequel That Never Got Made

Jim and John Thomas wanted to bring Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Dutch back too.

The cast of Predator. Image 20th Century Fox

Some Arnold Schwarzenegger fans would have you believe the Austrian Oak’s finest film performance came as the T-800 Model 101 cybernetic android assassin sent to kill Sarah Connor in The Terminator – but they would be wrong.

Schwarzenegger’s best acting is actually reserved for the film he would make three years later, as Major Alan “Dutch” Schaeffer in 1987’s Predator.

It’s a film that pulled off the unique coup of being loved by audiences and critics alike. A suitably scary sci-fi horror tale, Predator is also an awesome action movie, complete with an A-Team like assault on some South American rebels and a few killer lines to boot.

Arnie is particularly prolific in this department, with lines like “stick around”, “if it bleeds, we can kill it” and “Get to the choppppppa!” among the movie’s most iconic.

Arnold Schwarzenegger as Dutch in Predator.
Arnold Schwarzenegger In Predator Image 20th Century Fox

Yet by the time Predator 2 rolled around in 1990, Schwarzenegger’s Dutch, one of only two survivors from the first movie, was nowhere to be seen.

Danny Glover did a passable job in the city-based sequel, but it just wasn’t quite the same with Robert Rodriguez’s more recent Predators, the only sequel since  to even come close to replicating the feel of the original.

It could have been so different though. Predator writers and brothers Jim and John Thomas revealed as much during an event marking the original movie’s 30-year anniversary.

In the wake of the film’s success they had several bold ideas for where to take the franchise next and pretty much all of them sound better than Predator 2.

One of them would have seen Dutch return for another battle with the Predators:

“We had an idea where at the end [of Predator], with the burned up clearing where the explosion happens… [Predator 2] opens there. Predator’s invisible feet come into view and a hand plunges down into the dust, into the ashes, and brings up the Predator’s arm and then activates the computer and get’s a readout to see everything that had happened up to that time, focusing on Arnold, and “this is my target.” We went from there and we had to think of how to bring Arnold back into it.”

Carl Weathers and Arnold Schwarzenegger in Predator.

Ultimately, these plans were scrapped after Schwarzenegger turned down the chance to return for the sequel, following a dispute over money.

John Davis, who produced the two Predator movies, revealed as much, years later: “We should’ve had Arnold in the movie. The Deal broke down over $250,000, which is a shame. But it was moved from the jungle to the city. You have to create a freshness about it.”

That said, the Thomas brothers had an even bigger, bolder idea for the sequel that didn’t even require Schwarzenegger:

“We also had an idea about doing a World War II version in the Battle of the Bulge, in the middle of the winter. A German foot platoon and an American platoon separated and had a stalemate fighting each other off when the Predator shows up. They have to join together to defeat it. We thought the snow Predator effect would be quite different.”

The Predator boys.

Ultimately neither idea saw the light of day, but do offer a fascinating glimpse of what might have been. Fans are currently awaiting the release of The Predator, the latest reboot of the franchise.

This time round Shane Black, who actually appeared in the first movie, is writing and directing and, if actor Thomas Jane’s recent revelations about the film’s plot are to be believed, it’s going to be great.

Previous Post
Next Post
Loaded staff writer Jack Beresford has produced content for Lad Bible, Axonn Media and a variety of online sports and news media outlets.